December 04, 2011 Q & A

Why were the Ten Commandments omitted from Trinity Hymnal?

Question

In comparing the original 1961 Trinity Hymnal with the 1990 Trinity Hymnal, I noted that the Ten Commandments, found on the first page of the 1961 hymnal, are omitted from the 1990 hymnal. What is the reason for this omission?

Answer
The decision regarding the Ten Commandments in the 1990 revision of Trinity Hymnal was influenced by feedback from churches that had been using the original edition. Some opined that having the Law printed in the hymnal was unnecessary and worshipers could use personal or pew Bibles. Others held that the Law should be read by the pastor and that unison or responsive reading thereof by the congregation is improper. These and other considerations led the revision planning committee to recommend that the Commandments be omitted. Thank you for your inquiry.

Recent Questions

February 15, 2022
Is salvation the result of divine election?
December 21, 2021
Why Not Display Crosses on Church Buildings?
July 24, 2021
Are Church Records Public?
May 15, 2021
A Religion or a Way of life?
May 06, 2021
“Stations of the Cross”
December 04, 2020
Will God keep silent when we pray?
October 29, 2020
Is everything present for God?

Recent Archive Topics